Minnesota Vikings’ Quarterback Move Draws Criticism

The Minnesota Vikings seem to be keeping their options open regarding their quarterback situation, with potential for further additions in the future. However, they made a notable move earlier in the offseason by signing Sam Darnold to a one-year contract worth $10 million, following his stint as the San Francisco 49ers’ backup quarterback under Kyle Shanahan’s guidance, where he supported Brock Purdy during the 2023 season.

Darnold’s signing appears to serve as a precautionary measure, possibly indicating a reluctance to invest heavily in securing a top quarterback prospect in the NFL Draft. The contract offered to Darnold positions him within the realm of fringe starting quarterback salaries, suggesting a strategic approach to quarterback acquisition rather than a definitive commitment to him as the long-term solution.

Critics, including Pro Football Focus, have questioned the wisdom of the Vikings’ decision to sign Darnold, citing concerns about the financial investment and his performance. Brad Spielberger of PFF specifically criticized the move, highlighting the significant raise given to Darnold compared to his 2023 earnings and suggesting it might be a strategic move to avoid the pressure of trading up in the draft.

Despite criticisms, there is recognition of Darnold’s potential, especially considering his promising performances towards the end of the 2022 season with the Carolina Panthers. The departure of Kirk Cousins to Atlanta necessitated a significant move by the Vikings, particularly with their first-round draft pick at No. 11 overall.

Darnold’s development under Shanahan adds an element of uncertainty to his potential role with the Vikings. Depending on the team’s ability to trade up in the 2024 NFL Draft, they may opt to start a rookie quarterback like J.J. McCarthy or Drake Maye immediately, or allow them to learn behind Darnold initially.

However, if the Vikings fail to secure a higher draft position, entrusting Darnold with the starting role could be a risky proposition for the 2024 season, especially given his career statistics and the team’s aspirations to maintain a positive relationship with star wide receiver Justin Jefferson while aiming for a postseason return.